Avatar of Hanna Shnaider
About The Author: Hanna Shnaider
Head of Marketing at @fortyseven47 | PhD in Philology | Passionate About Modern Technologies | Bringing Digitalization Towards the Business.
More posts by Hanna Shnaider

A QA process maturity is the result of a company with an established product, customer base, and team. A robust testing strategy is essential to ensure that new features are released without bugs or unintended consequences. There are many models for developing a QA process depending on your organizational needs. 

Your company’s quality assurance (QA) process is something you need to consider. It can be the difference between a successful launch and an embarrassing failure. Whether your team is just starting out or you are looking for ways to improve, this blog post will help you get started with defining your QA process maturity level, models, and capabilities.

What’s in it for me? Why should I care about my Process Maturity Level? What does that even mean anyway? Do I have one? If not, what do I need to do next? These are all common questions when assessing your own process maturity level or when trying to make sense of the latest trends in software testing. This blog post offers each and everything to consider when you are thinking to build or improve your QA process.

So let’s get started

QA Process Maturity: Models and Capabilities - 2022 - 11

What is a QA Process Maturity Model and what does it do?

The QA Process Maturity Model provides an easy way to measure your current quality assurance practices and identify areas of improvement. This model will help you improve the effectiveness of your quality assurance processes by identifying gaps in your current system and providing recommendations on how you can close them.  

The Process Maturity Model was created by the Software Engineering Institute at Carnegie Mellon University. It has been used successfully by organizations around the world including NASA, General Motors, Intel Corporation, Siemens AG, Toyota Motor Corporation, and many others. 

You can use the QA Process Maturity Model to create a plan for improving your company’s quality practices. This model will help you understand how your current QA process is performing and what areas need improvement. Once you have assessed your current state, you can identify specific steps that can be used to implement new quality assurance processes with the goal of improving your company’s overall performance. 

As you work to improve your industry, you will need to demonstrate your progress to stakeholders including investors, regulators, and customers. The QAP Model can be used as part of this process by providing stakeholders with a clear roadmap for how improvement initiatives are progressing. This model will help you create easy-to-read reports that clearly show how much progress has been made and what is needed for future success.

What is Capability Maturity Model?

The Capability Maturity Model (CMM) provides a framework for assessing an organization’s software development processes and practices. CMM helps organizations identify the gaps in their current software development processes and then develop strategies to close those gaps, which will lead to higher quality products and more satisfied customers. 

It is a model that was developed by the Software Engineering Institute (SEI) for assessing the maturity of an organization’s processes. The SEI defined five levels of capability. These are, in order from least to most mature, Initial, Repeatable, Defined, Managed, and Optimizing. The CMM states that an organization’s process is never in the Defined or Managed levels, and therefore cannot benefit from improvement efforts. The implications of this assumption are widespread for software engineering organizations, particularly if their funding models depend on receiving contracts that require this level of maturity.

It is a way for organizations to assess the maturity of their processes, and to aspire to improve their processes. CMM is particularly relevant for organizations that create large software systems, either as products or as components of other products (e.g., embedded systems).

QA Process Maturity: Models and Capabilities - 2022 - 13

What is the maturity model in software testing?

The Testing Maturity Model (TMM) in Software Testing is a framework for evaluating the maturity of software testing processes. TMM was developed to help organizations improve their skills and knowledge of software testing. It was developed based on three key areas that have been shown to have a strong correlation with higher quality levels: R&D, process discipline, and product-driven test management.

In recent years, it has become more important for companies to invest in new technologies. For example, there is a rising interest from companies to invest in artificial intelligence and machine learning. However, rising adoption rates make organizations vulnerable to security risks. One of the main issues is the lack of awareness with regards to the risks that come with changes in technology.

The goal of employing a Testing Maturity Model is to assess the maturity and goals for improving software testing methodology. The successful adoption of a testing maturity model can help an organization identify areas for improvement, deliver more value to the business and provide better customer satisfaction.  

Organizations must use a Testing Maturity Model in order to assess their performance level. The goal of employing the Maturity Model also includes identifying areas for improvement, delivering more value to the business and providing better customer satisfaction. Organizations are increasingly investing in new technologies such as AI but they are not aware of the risks that come with this advancement. Another objective is employing the Maturity Model is to identify what skills are needed to improve performance. Organizations can use a Maturity Model to check their present level of skills and determine what skills they may need to acquire in order to improve performance.

How can an organization know which model they need for their specific needs?

An organization must know which model is best suited to its needs. This is because models such as the Testing Maturity Model (TMM) and CAPM both have different goals and methods of assessing the maturity level of an organization. The TMM focuses on improving software testing processes while CAPM helps organizations improve their process, product, and business outcomes. These models vary in their approach and focus on different areas of improvement. By using a model, companies identify the maximum value that they can gain from investments in product or process improvements. When considering which model is most suitable, companies should consider their needs and the focus of the model.

QA Process Maturity: Models and Capabilities - 2022 - 15

What are the elements of a QA maturity model?

The elements of a maturity model are terms that are used to describe different aspects of how well organizations can respond to changes. These elements are the following

Level One: In the Beginning – Work is done on an informal basis

This level of software development company is characterized by AD HOC initiatives and the organization isn’t thought out ahead of time.. 

Level Two: Repetitive – Work is organized and tracked again

At the outset, a project management function is not enough. In addition, software development organizations with this degree of functionality have a basic and consistent approach to tracking cost, scheduling, and functionality. The procedures are in place to repeat the previous success on projects with comparable applications.

Level Three: Defined – Work is well defined

At this stage, the software development process for both management and engineering functions is defined and documented

Level Four: Optimizing – Work is constantly improved and innovated upon

Management may effectively manage the software development project by using precise measurements.. At this stage, the organization set a numerical quality objective for both software process and maintenance.

The ability to manage a process or set of processes is known as quantitative process management. At this level, a process’s performance is kept in check using statistical and other mathematical algorithms, and its outcome can be foreseen quantitatively.

Level Five: Optimizing: Work is based on continuous improvement.

At this level, the software development process has continual improvements aimed to constantly improve performance. The software development process also aims for innovation constantly.

QA Process Maturity: Models and Capabilities - 2022 - 17

The benefits of having an established QA process maturity model for your business:

The benefits of having an established process maturity model for your business:

  • You can identify areas for improvement and invest in them over time, which will gradually increase the efficiency of your organization.
  • identifies areas that need to be developed and improved by the team. 
  • Helps teams align on goals and expectations. Helps improve customer satisfaction through better quality software products. 
  • Provides the means to identify and employ good practices for projects execution. 
  • Gather key business stakeholders around a single project activity, which will improve communication throughout the organization.
  • Identify what skills are needed for improving your performance.
  • Track your process improvement efforts.
QA Process Maturity: Models and Capabilities - 2022 - 19

Conclusion

The Testing Maturity Model (TMM) and CAPM both have different goals and methods of assessing the maturity level of an organization. The TMM focuses on improving software testing processes while CAPM helps organizations improve their process, product, and business outcomes. These models vary in their approach and focus on different areas of improvement. By using a model, companies identify the maximum value that they can gain from investments in product or process improvements. When considering which model is most suitable for your needs, you should think about what type of investment you want to make – either in terms of resources or time-to-value  – as well as how much effort will be required to implement it within your company culture. 

For instance, if you are looking for a quick win with a small investment in time and resources, the CAPM may be a better fit for your needs. If you are looking to make an extensive commitment to process improvement over the long term, the TMM is more suitable. Either way, both models can provide useful information about how well your organization is performing. If you need a QA specialist, just let us know.